Skip to content
Urban Reels Zone

Letterboxd's Most Dedicated Critics Are Transforming Film-Going Norms: 'I Was Excited to Pull Out My Phone'

I make a point to completely turn off my phone upon entering a theater. Not simply on vibrate – all the way off. I mention this not to boast, or to suggest that the spirit of a film legend will materialize to offer approval. I view it as one of life's minor indulgences: for no less than an hour and a half, I am totally incommunicado. I maintain my phone deactivated throughout the end credits as well. It strikes me as decadent to remain seated as fellow attendees trickle away, bathed in the light of the closing titles.

And, increasingly, by the glow of the cataloguing app.

In excess of 26 million individuals engage with Letterboxd, a film-cataloguing app. Like other curated brands, it has evolved into a cultural signifier for a certain breed of aficionado who hypes fresh cinema and revels in revisiting vintage films. Users score and write about films, and the most insightful or most illuminating commentaries become popular, motivating movie buffs to craft thoughtful responses.

"If I don't jot down my ideas immediately once the movie ends, my critiques are far less coherent and articulate," said Josh Stern.

During a trip to the theater, the end titles had just begun before the man seated in front of me began typing his thoughts. A few seats over, a couple remained seated, focused on their screens, noting their respective thoughts.

The renowned artist David Lynch once offered wisdom: note every brilliant thought the precise instant it comes to mind. Otherwise, it could vanish, and, as he put it: "Forgetting a great idea, you feel like you could commit suicide." Although Lynch advised hopeful creators, a similar ethos applies to the act of reviewing.

A student, a young university attendee in New York, always drafts his reviews before leaving the auditorium.

"Should I fail to articulate my impressions promptly once the movie ends, my critiques are much less clear and eloquent," he said. "The process demands a while. I take my time, and my girlfriend isn't fond of it."

He goes to the movies often – on 182 occasions last year – and is on a first-name basis with the ushers, who occasionally have to ask him to leave so they can start tidying the rows. He considers it acceptable to utilize the credit sequence: "When you purchase a theater ticket, the closing sequence are part of the film experience."

The platform's most passionate users give credit to the service with reviving excitement around a struggling movie business, where output has decreased and work is scarce. (Letterboxd also boasts the sort of demographics brands seek – its primary group of users is aged 18 and 24, with those aged 25 to 35.)

Excitement begets further excitement; highly awaited movies see a flurry of engagement on Letterboxd right after the premiere showtimes. The highest-rated review of a divisive adaptation – "the novelist succumbed long ago yet this adaptation is still the most egregious event that has ever happened to her" – has received in excess of 50,000 hearts. Another fictionalized retelling generated this contrast to a pop star's concert film: "the Eras Tour documentary discovered deceased."

"It's somewhat an addiction," commented Ben Glidden, a 33-year-old resident who is employed in marketing. He also chooses to compose critiques in the credits. "Processing what you just saw, right after you saw it, aids the cinematic journey. It clarifies the key messages of a film. If it produces a feeling of contentment, that's hardly something you retain hours later."

Glidden feels most motivated to critique a film if it was brilliant – or exceptionally bad. Case in point: he recently sat through a sci-fi vehicle. "I found myself so disappointed by how egregiously bad it was, that I was excited to pull out my phone and assign it a lowest possible review," he noted. (Glidden is a more critical critic than established professional critics, who awarded the film a higher rating, calling it "smart and entertaining material.")

A social media manager, a twenty-eight-year-old professional who manages social media, saw an acclaimed movie at a neighborhood theater and stayed to compose the review ("it got five stars"). He has witnessed more egregious conduct: people taking out their phones to review the movie they are currently watching. "That irritates me," he admitted.

One of film's most enduring urban legends describes a exhibition of an 1896 film that depicted a train pulling into a station. Film was in its earliest days and – according to this apocryphal anecdote – the image of a locomotive moving right toward the camera frightened the spectators so much that people scattered screaming.

Over a century later, audience behavior remains just as problematic. Often, individuals remember how to behave in a theater any more, particularly when the lights dim: viewers take pictures of the screen, smuggle in strong-smelling food, and, as seen during a cultural moment, occasionally participate in outright brawls.

Certain people have resorted to social media to argue over the appropriateness of writing reviews during the credits. When one social media user

Written by

Angela Garcia

A travel writer and urban explorer passionate about uncovering hidden gems in cities around the globe.

Urban Reels Zone

Type to search articles.